It was on Yom Kippur this year that Nadav Weiman first sensed the documentary NAZA was having a significant impact in Israel – that’s despite the fact that back in September, when the Jewish festival fell, barely a handful of Israelis had seen the film.
Weiman lives in Shapira, a secular, left-leaning suburb of Tel Aviv. Days before the high holy day, NAZA had premiered at the Venice film festival. As Weiman mooched between friends and neighbours on the public holiday, almost everyone was discussing the documentary they were yet to watch. The tenor of reaction was almost universally hostile, he concedes, even among his more liberal peers. “Yes, almost all had very hardline views about the movie,” he tells me. “But, everyone was talking about it.”
Encouraging discussion and debate about the actions of Israeli’s military is Weiman’s life’s work. He is the executive director of Breaking the Silence, a veteran-led Israeli NGO which has, for over 20 years, attempted to, in its words, “expose the public to the reality of everyday life in the occupied territories”. Primarily, it does this by collecting testimonies from soldiers who have served in Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem.
He was surprised by NAZA’s sudden ubiquitousness. The film’s material is shocking – it details the secret systems that have left tens of thousands of civilians dead, and millions more homeless, displaced and injured in Gaza, building on revelations first published by the Israeli-Palestinian magazine +972, the Hebrew-language news outlet Local Call and the Guardian between 2023 and 2025. While journalists, including some in Gaza, have documented the consequences of Israel’s military campaign, NAZA offers in cinematic form first-hand testimonies from officers tasked with implementing commands.
Central to this is the concept of “nezek agavi”, the film’s namesake acronym which refers to the number of civilians expected to be killed in any military attack: human life signed off as collateral damage.
Hitting a nerve
Certain explanations for NAZA’s resonance domestically are clear. “Most Israelis don’t consume international media when it’s in English,” Weiman says. This is a Hebrew-language film, directed by Israelis. Evidence comes direct from soldiers, not international interlocutors. The intelligence units in which these soldiers have served are prestigious – mostly desk-based, not on the frontline. “These are people who live in Tel Aviv, vote for more progressive parties, work in hi-tech jobs … They killed hundreds of Palestinians from the air, many it seems without blinking twice. That’s hitting a particular nerve here.”
Then there’s the political climate: these last few months have been especially tense in Israel, as national election campaigns played out across the country. “For the right wing it is very helpful to attack [the Israeli directors] Yuval and Rachel,” he says. “It plays into their everyone-is-out-to-get-us narrative.”
Still, Neiman’s experience had been that the reporting of what has taken place in the war on Gaza had been largely ignored in Israel.
Breaking the Silence has collected over 1000 testimonies to date (Weiman’s is among them). And, hundreds of testifiers have come forward to the NGO in the last three years, after atrocities committed by Hamas on 7 October in Gaza. Mostly, he says, Israeli publications and TV channels declined to platform or report on them.
Israeli media, he says, has failed (or actively refused) to cover what’s happening inside Gaza. “There continues to be an iron wall between the Gaza Strip and the rest of Israel,” says Weiman. “We don’t hear complex ideas or views, or have mainstream access to information. Certainly not related to collateral damage. ‘Everyone in Gaza is assisting terrorists’ – that’s the line we’re told.” The meticulous detail in NAZA, therefore, is particularly confronting.
A broken system
The backlash has been predictably rapid and harsh. Israeli military chief of staff Eyal Zamir has said they will use “every tool at our disposal” against the film, while protesters gathered outside Szor’s parent’s home, demanding that she face the death penalty. Benjamin Netanyahu vowed to try to strip their citizenship. It’s all an effort, Weiman says, to scare off critics and dissenters. “They want silence.”
For most Israelis, national service is compulsory. Nobody wants to hear uncomfortable truths, he says, about their friends, relatives or neighbours. It’s an attitude of wilful ignorance his team has repeatedly encountered. “When soldiers speak out, they are labelled traitors. The narrative here are these are conversations to be held behind closed doors; within the system … People who say no, it’s actually the system itself that is broken or corrupt? It’s a much harder pill to swallow.”
And this is precisely what NAZA does. “The film shows that the system is the problem,” says Weiman. “Not the irregularities, but the commands and how we fight. The terms on which the military operates.” The military can rebuff individual cases as isolated incidents and the work of bad apples. “But a cluster of 24 soldiers speaking, individually, about this proves this is systemic,” says Weiman. “It’s too many to write-off or ignore.”
A shift in opinion
While all identities in NAZA are concealed to protect the safety of sources, it’s clear at least some soldiers interviewed are grappling with shame after their actions during active service. Weiman knows first-hand what it takes to face these regrets: 20 years ago, he served in a reconnaissance unit of the Nahal infantry brigade as a combat soldier on a sniper team.
The extreme response to NAZA in Israel has started to affect Breaking the Silence’s work. “Now our testifiers want even more and more assurances and protection before speaking,” he says. “This fear is exactly what the government wanted. The stakes now feel far higher.”
There’s precedent in Israel for the parameters of public debate shifting, despite this intended culture of silence. And Weiman’s sense is that international activity – policy, pressure, journalism – can be a key driver for change in Israel. He points to sanctions on violent West Bank settlers introduced during the Biden administration. “The minute Biden enforced sanctions, a light was shed on a problem and dismissing it here was harder.” This week, the UK announced its own raft of sanctions.
But there’s a long way to go: while no majority was achieved in Israel’s elections at the end of last month, Netanyahu’s far-right bloc still won the largest number of seats; opposition parties are hardly led by peaceniks.
His hope is that NAZA might form part of a shift in public opinion at least. “There is already a lot more debate in the public sphere about Gaza,” he says. ‘NAZA’ as a phrase has entered the national lexicon. And that’s despite the fact that, while the film has been offered to a number of distributors and cinemas in Israel, it has not yet been screened there.
“The thirst for conversation here is growing,” says Weiman. Soon, Israelis will be able to watch NAZA for themselves, and Weiman – and other activists like him – will be there to keep the conversation going, whatever the headwinds. “The most important thing for me is to speak to Israelis; it’s a movie about us, we need to change.”
No comments:
Post a Comment
Keep a civil tongue.